Tag Archives: Gotye


After looking at what’s happening on the songwriting side of things yesterday, I wanted to examine the state of the industry overall. The numbers point to some signs of weakness in sales. We only have one million selling album for the first time in 21 years of Soundscan. Gold albums declined from 16 to 11. Even on the track sales side, we’ve declined from 52 million selling songs to 47, despite a 6% overall uptick. This suggests that there’s a marked increase in “medium-selling” tracks, which could be good news, especially for independents.

Overall, the decline in album sales continues to be a concern, or as Paul Resnikoff states, Kiss Your Album Sales Recovery Goodbye. Album sales are down 3.2% overall, despite a 13.8% increase in digital album sales. Yet dig deeper and there are more interesting trends. Catalog sales had another up year, increasing 5.4%. So the decline came at the expense of new music. I would say there are several factors contributing to this.

First, take a look at our top 3 sellers of the year. They are all new acts on their first hit. And one of those acts (important fact) doesn’t have an album. Given the YTD sales of Gotye and Fun, if Carly Rae Jepsen had released a full length album, it’s likely she would have made up as much as 10% of the differential gap between this year’s sales and last. Maroon 5 has 2 of the top selling tracks of the year, but their album was only out for one week of this comparison. Had it come out 3 weeks earlier, it too might have covered another 5% of the gap. But either way, traditional buying habits show many people purchase an album after they know more than one song. So having the top songs come from new acts would suggest a slightly down market for album sales in any case.

Now let’s take a look at those catalog sales. Those numbers have been going up for the last 2 years largely due to the return of the bins in the front of Wal-Mart and Best Buy stores selling older titles for $4.99. The prominent positioning at retail is now going to cheap, older titles thereby driving up their sales. Both Wal-Mart and Best Buy have increasingly placed their new music releases in harder to find places. My local Best Buy has the top sellers positioned down a regular aisle facing the rear of the store blocked by an aisle of hair dryers. Wal-Mart has been moving their CD racks to the mid-point of the media sections. You’d be hard pressed to get sales if it’s not in a visible place by which to sell the product.

Then, once you get to the sales racks, most of the CDs are going for $11.99. Gone are the days of discounting in order to drive people into the store. There are also many deluxe editions going for $16.99 and up. In some ways, I think this is good to drive revenues into the business. Especially to get the die hard fans to pay more for first-in-market deluxe editions. On the other hand, once the fans have the record and the album has been out a month, $11.99 is hardly an impulse price. Not having enough titles priced under $10 on a regular basis is going to harm overall sales figures. One just needs to look at the economy (and the bins in the front of the store) to know price is a contributing factor to sales declines.

I wouldn’t bank on albums for the business as a whole. Why would I start singles label if I did? But I wouldn’t give up hope on the album overall. I would just look to better pricing and release strategies to boost the numbers overall.

Billboard also noted that Pop and Rock are ruling the mid-year charts. But I guess that this is all how you determine what is rock. The two artists propelling rock to a top category are Gotye and Fun. Yet the defining element to their “rock” definition seems to be airplay on rock radio. I hear these songs and I hear well-written left-of-center pop songs. I know each act would do great at a rock festival like Coachella, but Snoop Dogg plays there as well. Overall, I think we’re in an era where many songs and artists are tough to place in a genre box. So when Billboard states Rock tracks outsold Pop tracks, this is largely because of how these acts are categorized.

Rock, in particular, has a tough identity crisis which leads me to be skeptical of any stats involving this genre. One can hear Carly Rae Jepsen and clearly say “Pop”. One can hear David Guetta and clearly say “Electronic” or “Dance”. One can hear Kanye West and say “Hip-hop” and Eric Church is clearly “Country”. Yet say Gotye, Maroon 5 or Train to different people and you’ll get different genre answers.

It’s also fair to say that Hip-Hop is headed in this direction as well. Is Nicki Minaj’s “Starships” an Electronic song, a Pop Song, or a Hip-Hop song? Or for that matter Flo Rida’s “Wild Ones”? The answer is all of the above making genre classifications that much harder to rely on. If anything, those songs and even the fungible rock songs are examples of multiple genres influencing songs, which I predicted would continue to be a common element of hit songs.

What does this all mean? It means we’re an industry in flux. The ground is shifting on what the prevailing sound will become. The strategies are consistently evolving on how to market and release albums and track. We haven’t even begun to discuss the ever growing percentage of revenue coming from items not here, including streaming and sync income. We have clearly not arrived on a definitive model for the business’ future, nor will we in the short term. What we do have is a business still in flux and still being redefined. Yet knowing tomorrow will not be like today just means taking risks. If people in the industry continually take those risks and find new elements to make it, we will find plenty more growth in music in the years ahead.


Another 6 months down, and time for another Futurehit 2012 Midyear report. There’s lots of stats to chew on. Single download sales are up. Album sales are down. Two songs sold over 5 million downloads in 6 months. What’s really interesting is that I see signs of an industry ready to go thru another major shift musically and financially. Where this will lead is an increased reliance on digital singles and a re-examination of passive fans and how they will contribute to a future music business.


To start, let’s group out the Top 3 selling singles so far this year. Collectively, they have sold nearly 15 million downloads in the US alone. 2.2% of all downloads sold came from these 3 songs, which is pretty impressive. But can you find the trend in these three songs? The truth is that these songs are all radically different in texture, style, rhythm and theme. The top seller, Gotye, has an 18 second intro which runs counter to my theories of short intros. Fun. has a rhythm change in the song that hasn’t existed in a top hit in years. In other words, they broke the mold. What this suggests to me is that people are indeed may be tiring of the sameness found in many of today’s hits and they are ready for a new sound. I’m not sure the new sound is found in either of these songs, but the same sounding Euro-influenced dance pop may be waning.

Also worth noting that the top 3 sellers are also the first time any of those artists ever hit in the US. The notion of superstars ruling the charts is quickly being disproven with this trio. What’s also worth paying attention to is that while it’s their first US hit, it’s not their first release. All of them have been making music for a few years in one form or another, so it’s not that they got lucky their first go-round. They developed over several years. In fact, despite the notion that always exists of labels signing young artists, these singers are aged 32, 30 and 26 respectively. Signing that 17 year old is not necessarily the ticket to huge stardom.

These artists were largely not developed within the major label system. Two of these acts, Gotye and Carly Rae Jepsen, were created under completely independent labels that then got “upstreamed” to the majors. Fun. was signed to a major, but under the Fueled By Ramen imprint that has maintained some independence from its parent company Warner Music Group. In the top 50 selling singles, there is not one track that is 100% independent. There are only two songs out of the Top 50 that were created as an indie. And they are the #1 and #3 best sellers of the year so far. To some degree, this underscores the continued importance of major labels on big hit songs, but also that big creative hits do come from outside the system.

The sheer success of these songs (they are the only ones selling over 4 million apiece this year) leads me to feel that the public is starting to clamor for something different. They really want a unique spice in their life that is not the same repetitive rhythms. Naturally, it has to be a great song as well, so don’t be different just for the sake of being so. Make no mistake, these are also very well structured songs with universal themes as well. Yet sonically, there’s a strong argument to not emulate what you’re hearing across the board.

Or is there? Because once you venture outside of the Top 50, you find that there are a lot of similarities in the songs. While the Top 3 are outliers, taken as a whole there is still a general pattern and formula to what elements one needs in a successful song.

The average length of intros in the Top 50 selling songs is still around the 7 second mark. 7.7 seconds to be exact. But that’s also a bit misleading as one song, Coldplay’s “Paradise”, has a 61 second intro. Take that song out and the average intro length of a top selling song is 6.5 seconds. Once again, about 1/4 (24%) of the hits have no intro whatsoever. And only 30% of the hits have an intro of 9 seconds or more. In fact, in the top 10, only the Gotye song has an intro longer than 9 seconds.

There’s no mistake that overall the rhythmic thumping that you’re hearing is working. Over half the Top 50 sellers (56%) have tempos of 116 BPM or greater. Digging deeper, the generally accepted Euro-dance BPM (between 125 and 130 BPM) covers over 1/3 (36%) of the top sellers. Even Gotye doesn’t escape this, as it’s 129 BPM rhythm is certainly a reason why it’s been favored by remixers around the world.

Contrary to my expectations in Futurehit.DNA, mid-tempo songs aren’t making a comeback as 20% of the top selling songs fall between 95 and 112 BPM. My theory as to why this is happening is probably due to a couple of factors. One is that the rapid ADD attitude reinforced by an on-demand world with everything at your fingertips causes people to gravitate to songs that are working at the presumed speeds of their brains. There’s not a lot of downtime. Then, add in a growing club culture reinforcing fast songs appropriate for the environment and radio programmers reluctant to bring the energy down. All this adds up to a reinforced tempo that’s unlikely to recede anytime soon. The energy is in the air.

Two of the top 3 songs of the year (Fun. and Carly Rae Jepsen) are sung in a major key certainly suggesting that people are looking for very happy tunes. In fact, when I first started to formulate what I was going to write, I thought I was going to point to Gotye as a minor key outlier. In actuality, it’s the major key songs that are the outliers. Of the Top 50 selling songs, 2/3 of them are either in a minor key or contain a relative minor. Specific to the relative minor, it appears that there’s been a noticeable spike in its usage this year with 18% of the top songs containing it. Whether the reason comes from a downbeat mood over economy or other reasons, it is clear that minor keys are desired more by audiences today.

Another overall summary I would recommend reading for the first half of the year is this analysis by Billboard.


The Gotye song “Somebody That I Used To Know” has really taken off in the US. It had the 4th biggest sales week ever for a digital single and even became the first single to have three weeks of sales over 400,000. It’s clearly a worldwide smash with over 200 million YouTube views, so is there lessons to learn from this song?

I admit that Gotye does not appear on the surface to fit the theories I discuss in Futurehit.DNA. My first discussion of this song was in August, 2011 after the song had been out a month and was exploding in Australia. A top industry exec friend asked me, “Is this a US hit?” My response then, as it is now, was “It doesn’t really fit modern Top 40 theories, but it has that compelling special something.” There are five key takeaways that you can use as you work to create your own hit.

The assumption is that you have to make songs that are produced and homogenized like everything else out there. The facts rarely support this. More of the top selling songs in the last few years come from the one that didn’t sound like everyone else. This year, both Gotye and Fun. are dominating single sales without being like anyone else.

People have asked me why “Somebody That I Used To Know” works so well. I just say it’s a new version of the Human League song “Don’t You Want Me”. That early 80s hit had a structure where the male singer pleaded for the woman in the first verse and the woman explained why she wouldn’t come back in the second verse. Gotye copied that subject exactly. While everyone else seems to write direct love song pleas, he mined a tested theme that had been unused recently.

Play the first 15 seconds of the song and then the last 30 seconds. The beginning is very soft and sparse, with the memorable xylophone line. The end is a colliding cornucopia of harmonies, counter melodies, and electronics. They are at a significantly higher emotional level than the beginning. The song is a journey to get to that point. Make the song the journey. Flat dynamics and emotions will not win.

People have asked me if this song invalidates the 7 second rule in Futurehit.DNA. It doesn’t because of how the song worked with the platform playing it. In the video that broke the song, the 19 second intro became compelling because of a long tracking shot of the left side of the singer’s naked body. Skin sells, and the mere fact that the open teased sex and nudity kept the viewer engaged. The extra body painting and time lapse stuff that the video is known for kept you there. But the allure of nudity drew the listener in. When it came time to deliver the song to US radio, the intro was cut down to 8 seconds to conform to Top 40’s short attention span.


One thing I’ve been preaching a lot lately is that many bands fail to have a hit because they give up on their song too quickly. They presume the few weeks around the release is all you have to do and if it doesn’t pop, it’s done. The opposite is true. Gotye came out in Australia in July 2011 and peaked in the US in April 2012. I was aware of the song in July, as were many others. But it still took a long methodical campaign with a lot of work by UniversalRepublic to make sure it hit a mass level. Sticking with a song is key to its success. I’ve been working with a song for nearly a year that now has over 300,000 views and 10,000 singles sold. This weekend, the song was shared on Facebook at a rate of about 3 times an hour. There are about 100 videos that use or cover the song on YouTube. This didn’t happen overnight. This was a lot of time and work put into it. With more work to come.